The dynamic behavior of the cylindrical shell can be predicted by more simplified beam models for a wide range of applications. The present paper deals with finding design conditions in which the cylindrical shell performs like a beam. Employing the Hamilton’s principle, the governing equations are obtained using both Donnell-Mushtari and Flugge shell theories and the analytical solution is obtained for long cylinders with simply-supported boundary conditions at both ends. Then, by equalizing the shell and beam vibration frequencies, the shell-to-beam transition conditions are obtained for both theories. To account for the effects of shear distortion and rotatory inertia of the shell, the finite element method is applied to find the best transition conditions with less approximating assumptions. Finally, the effects of boundary conditions on the transition parameters as well as the frequency response are studied. The obtained conditions simply define that if the shell can be assumed as a beam in any specific geometrical and material conditions.