Trade-in services, coupled with technological innovation for product update, are widely adopted by businesses. However, the practical implications of this strategy for enterprise operations and consumer purchasing behavior remain unclear, necessitating further exploration of how firms should respond. This study investigates a manufacturer offering trade-in services by comparing two scenarios: one where the manufacturer implements technological innovation and another where it refrains from doing so. Through the development of decision-making models and a comparative analysis of game-theoretic results, we examine the effects on enterprise operations and consumer responses to technological innovation. Additionally, we conduct a factor analysis to assess the determinants of technological innovation’s impact. Our findings reveal that, under trade-in services, technological innovation enhances the manufacturer’s profitability but may also lead to supplier hitchhiking. Both new and existing consumers exhibit homogeneous responses to innovation; however, under certain conditions, technological innovation may trigger consumer resistance. Furthermore, trade-in services can generate a synergistic effect with technological innovation, amplifying both its positive and negative consequences. Based on these insights, we propose operational adjustments to mitigate the identified adverse effects. This research provides managerial guidance for optimizing decision-making and addressing consumer reactions when implementing technological innovation in trade-in supply chains.
